Originally posted posted Thu, 13 Nov 2003
I came across an interesting essay, Consumer
Angst, today. It mirrors very well what I feel about products that
try to ride on advertising instead of innovation. Take Microsoft, also
known as the evil empire, and Linux. Everyone (well almost everyone)
agrees that Linux is more scalable and robust than Microsoft <
insert your Windows version > . Yet, there is this amorphous
resentment, this inclination to trust a glossy advertisement more than
an impartial report by your IT department. Well, my bile seems to be
spreading all around and getting out of hand, so I will return back to
the essay.
The reason I like the essay is that instead of ranting (like me),
he fleshes out the issue very well. Here is an excerpt from the essay
Here are some examples of the minor lies that are
included n advertising to support the big lie:
"New!" - How can
something be simultaneously new and absolutely essential to
survival? Or, given the thesis that new is better, the advertiser
should honestly list the ways that the old new product failed us, thus
setting the stage for inevitable disenchantment with the new new
product.
Another of my favorite quote (and
especially relevant in an argument between Linux and Microsoft) is
"It costs more, but it is worth it." By
implication, things that cost more are worth more, and by negation,
things that have no price also have no value. This is an appeal to
reject the entire natural world out of hand.